Residual Stress

 

Residual stresses are locked-in stresses within a metal object, even though the object is free of external forces.  These stresses are the result of one region of the metal being constrained by adjacent regions from expanding, contracting, or releasing elastic strains.  Residual stresses can be tensile or compressive.  In fact, tensile and compressive residual stresses co-exist within a component.

See metallurgy courses & webinars
Need help with a failure analysis?

Causes of residual stress

Residual stresses arise whenever a component is stressed beyond its elastic limit and plastic deformation occurs.  Plastic deformation occurs when the stress exceeds a metal’s yield strength (discussed in Tensile Testing).  This can be as a result of…

  • Non-uniform plastic deformation during mechanical processing, such as that during rolling, forming operations (bending or drawing), machining, and mechanical surface treatments (shot peening and roller burnishing).
  • Phase transformations during cooling from elevated temperatures
  • Non-uniform plastic deformation during heating or cooling
  • Heterogeneity of a chemical or crystallographic order (nitriding or case hardening)
  • Various surface treatments (enameling, electroplating PVD and CVD coating)

This article discusses the first three causes.

Residual stress due to temperature variations

In parts cooled from elevated temperatures, residual stresses are caused by temperature variations in the metal during cooling.  Cooling from elevated temperatures occurs during heat treating and welding.

Temperature variations in a metal during cooling from an elevated temperature result in localized variations of the amount of thermal contraction.  Thermal contraction develops non-uniform stress due to different rates of cooling experienced by the surface and interior of the metal.  During cooling, the outer portion of a component cools first and that portion of the metal contracts, compressing the hotter inner metal.  As the inner portion of the component cools, the metal tries to contract, but is constrained by the already cooled outer portion.  Consequently, the inner portion will have a residual tensile stress and the outer portion of the component will have a residual compressive stress.

Residual stress due to phase transformation

A phase transformation is a change in the metallurgical phases present in an alloy.  For example, the transformation from austenite to martensite in steel during through hardening is a phase transformation.

Residual stresses that arise during a phase transformation are due to the volume difference between the newly forming and initial  metallurgical phases.  The volume difference causes expansion or contraction of the metal.

For phase transformations that occur during cooling from an elevated temperature, such as in steel, the outer portions of the metal cool first and undergo the phase transformation first.  If the volume of the new phase is different from the volume of the initial phase, then the transformed volume of metal will change as the new phase forms.  As the interior of the metal cools it will also try to increase or decrease in volume.  However, the volume change of the metal interior will be constrained by the cooler outer layer of metal that has already transformed.

When the volume of the new phase is larger than the volume of the initial phase, the center portion of the component will be under compression and the surface will be under tension.  When the volume of the new phase is less than the volume of the initial phase, the center portion of the component will be under tension and the portion of the metal at and near the surface will be under compression.

For example, during through hardening of steel during a quench, austenite transforms to martensite, with the martensite having a volume that is about 4% greater than austenite.  During the quench, the steel at the surface transforms to martensite first since the surface cools the fastest.  As the metal at the interior continues to cool, it transforms to martensite.  However, its volume expansion is restricted by the hardened, cooler surface layer. This restraint causes the interior to be under compression and the outer surface under tension (see Metallurgy of Steel Through Hardening).

In some conditions, the volume changes can produce residual stresses large enough to cause plastic deformation, leading to component warping or distortion.  With severe quenching the quenching stresses can be so large that they cause cracking.

Residual stresses caused by mechanical treatment

Residual stresses also arise when plastic deformation is non-uniform through the cross-section of an item being deformed such as during bending, drawing, rolling, and extruding.  When a metal undergoes plastic deformation, a portion of the deformation is elastic (discussed in Tensile Testing).  After the load causing the deformation is removed, the metal tries to recover the elastic portion of the deformation.  However, the elastic recovery is incomplete because it is opposed by the adjacent plastically deformed material.

Consider a metal item that has been bent.  Regions adjacent to the bend will have been only elastically deformed, and this region will try to recover, a phenomenon known as springback.  After removing the external force, the regions which have been bent prevent the adjacent regions from undergoing complete elastic recovery to the non-deformed condition.  These regions are left in a state of residual tension and the regions which were plastically deformed are in a state of residual compression.

In general, the sign of the residual stress produced by non-uniform deformation will be opposite the sign of the plastic deformation which produced the residual stress.

See metallurgy courses & webinars
Need help with a failure analysis?

Effects of residual stress

Residual stresses can be beneficial or detrimental, depending on whether the stress is tensile or compressive.  Tensile residual stresses can be large enough to cause component distortion or cracking.  Also, fatigue and stress corrosion cracking require the presence of tensile stresses.  Because residual stresses are algebraically summed with applied stresses, surface residual tensile stresses combined with an applied tensile stress can reduce the reliability of components.  In fact, a residual tensile stress is sometime sufficient to cause stress corrosion cracking.

Surface residual compressive stresses are generally helpful because they reduce the effects of applied tensile stresses. In most cases, surface compressive stresses contribute to the improvement of fatigue strength and resistance to stress-corrosion cracking.

Controlling residual stress

Controlling the type and magnitude of residual stress is important for applications in which components will be exposed to fatigue or stress corrosion cracking conditions or if the residual stresses are large enough to cause component deformation or cracking.  This can be achieved through mechanical treatment, stress relief heat treatment, control of heat treating processes, and alloy selection.

Mechanical treatments such as shot peening, light cold rolling, stretching, and small amounts of compressing are used to intentionally induce a compressive residual stress at the surface of a component.

Because metal yield strength decreases as its temperature increases, metals can be stress relieved by heating to a temperature where the yield strength of the metal is the same or less than the magnitude of the residual stress. At this temperature, the metal can undergo microscopic plastic deformation, thus releasing at least a portion of the residual stress.  After stress relieving, the maximum residual stress that can remain is equal to the yield strength of the material at the stress-relieving temperature.

From a component processing perspective, residual stresses can be minimized by using reduced cooling rates to reduce temperature variations and allow for phase transformations to occur more uniformly throughout a component’s cross-section.  Also, alloys can be selected that alloy for slower cooling rates to be used, while still getting the desired phase transformations to occur.  For example, for carbon steel components to be through hardened, low-alloy carbon steels enable the use of slower cooling rates compared to plain carbon steels.

Measuring residual stresses

X-ray diffraction is used for measuring residual stress nondestructively.  With this technique, strains in the metal’s atomic crystal lattice are measured, and the residual stresses are then calculated based on the strain measurements.

Bibliography

  • G.E. Dieter, Mechanical Metallurgy, McGraw-Hill, 1986.
  • Krauss, Steels: Processing, Structure, and Performance, ASM International, 2005.
  • I.C. Noyan and J.B. Cohen, Residual Stress Measurement by Diffraction and Interpretation, Springer-Verlag, 1987.
  • "A group of us took several courses (Principles of Metallurgy, Metallurgy of Steel, Corrosion of Metals) to become more knowledgeable about the science of metals to avoid problems. For me, the biggest impact of the training was on working with suppliers. I feel more confident asking questions and I now know the suppliers which know their stuff and which ones don’t. And it was great being able to get the training when it was convenient for me."

    Sam Bloodgood, VP Process Improvement, Hydraforce, Inc.
  • "I oversee several operations, including steel heat treating and laser welding. However, my background was in the construction materials industry. Principles of Metallurgy gave me the knowledge to have meaningful discussions with my engineers and be able to ask them better questions."

    Tom Parkman, Plant Manager, Simonds International.
  • “Principles of Metallurgy exceeded my expectations. The content was straightforward enough not to be burdensome, yet deep enough to provide a practical review of fundamental principles. I recommend this course to any engineer or technical person who has been out of school and working in industry for several years, but not necessarily having been focused on metallurgy.”

    Andy Jacobs, Staff Engineer, DePuy Orthopaedics, Inc.
  • “The Principles of Metallurgy course is broke up into convenient length modules that can be fit into the busiest schedule. The course is a good review for engineers who had a materials class ten or more years ago.”

    Paul Flury B/E Aerospace
  • “This is an excellent course (Metallurgy of Steel Heat Treating) for learning basic heat treating practices. The course introduces and covers a broad range of processes. I would recommend it for anyone in the steel business.”

    Jim Marks, Magellan Corporation
  • “This course has given me more confidence in my job and given me a better understanding of some of the heat treatments used in the business.”

    Mark Winter, Abbey Forged Products

Have more questions? Email mpfeifer@imetllc.com or call 847.528.3467

Why Industrial Metallurgists?

  • Practical, up-to-date content.
  • Metallurgy expertise and 20+ years of experience.
  • Courses designed for non-metallurgists.
  • Training accessible from anywhere with internet access.
  • Engaging content.
  • Convenience. Learn when it suits your schedule.
  • Avoid being overwhelmed with too much information at one time. Set your own pace.