Materials Selection for Great Products: Overview

 

There are several situations during the life cycle of a product when a design team selects a material to use for a component or a joint between components – new product development, cost reduction, improve product performance and reliability, and improve manufacturing or assembly yields. Regardless of the situation, the goals are the same – find the lowest cost material that enables the product’s performance and reliability. There are several steps to the material selection process. This article provides an overview of this process.

materials selectionThe performance, reliability, and cost of any product depends on the performance, reliability, and cost of its components and the joints between components. And the performance, reliability, and cost of components and joints depend on two things: 1) their physical construction and 2) the materials of which they are made. Physical construction refers to shape and dimensions. Examples of different physical constructions are shown in the figure for two different size shafts and two different types of weld joints.

See metallurgy courses & webinars
Need help with a failure analysis?

Failure analysis results

So, the materials used in a product have a huge impact on the product’s success. Select materials with properties that don’t enable meeting the product’s performance or reliability requirements and be prepared to have poor sales or many returns. Select materials that are more expensive than necessary or are difficult to work with during manufacturing and assembly and be prepared to endure lower than expected profits.

These problems can be avoided by adopting a rigorous approach to the materials selection process, with an eye on selecting materials that optimize product performance reliability and cost. The materials selection process for a component or joint between components involves these steps:

  1. Identify the design requirements
  2. Identify the materials selection criteria.
  3. Identify candidate materials.
  4. Evaluate candidate materials.
  5. Select materials.

While each step might seem obvious, there are many organizations that do not have the structure in place to follow each step. Consequently, they end up selecting sub-optimum materials. The remainder of this article gives a brief overview of each step of the materials selection process. Future articles will provide more details about each step of the process.

Step 1: Identify the design requirements
The design requirements include the following items:

  • Performance requirements
  • Reliability requirements
  • Size, shape, and mass requirements
  • Cost requirements
  • Manufacturing and assembly requirements
  • Industry standards
  • Government regulations
  • Intellectual property requirements
  • Sustainability requirements

Identifying as many of the requirements as possible is critical for increasing the likelihood of learning whether potential materials exist. For many products, some of these requirements are not applicable, making the information gathering process easier. Regardless, as the number of requirements increases, the chance of finding a set of potential materials decreases.

Step 2: Identify materials selection criteria
The materials selection criteria are specific materials properties derived from the requirements identified during Step 1. For example, for a component that must support a specific load, the minimum yield stress that is required for the component’s material can be determined. This will be one of the material selection criteria.

Step 3: Identify candidate materials
Use the materials selection criteria to rule out materials that will not satisfy all the materials selection criteria. When evaluating whether a material might be appropriate for the application, be sure to consider the materials’ range of values for the properties of interest. Do not rely upon nominal properties values.

See metallurgy courses & webinars
Need help with a failure analysis?

Failure analysis results

Step 4: Evaluate candidate materials
There may be candidate materials for which there insufficient data available to indicate whether the materials satisfy certain selection criteria. These materials will have to be analyzed and tested to determine whether they do meet the selection criteria.
Step 5: Select materials
Select the materials that satisfy all the materials selection criteria at the lowest cost. Remember, cost includes the cost of the material and the cost to fabricate a component or form a joint between components.

Detailed information about the materials selection process is in my textbook Materials Enables Designs: A Materials Engineering Perspective to Product Design and Manufacturing.

  • "A group of us took several courses (Principles of Metallurgy, Metallurgy of Steel, Corrosion of Metals) to become more knowledgeable about the science of metals to avoid problems. For me, the biggest impact of the training was on working with suppliers. I feel more confident asking questions and I now know the suppliers which know their stuff and which ones don’t. And it was great being able to get the training when it was convenient for me."

    Sam Bloodgood, VP Process Improvement, Hydraforce, Inc.
  • "I oversee several operations, including steel heat treating and laser welding. However, my background was in the construction materials industry. Principles of Metallurgy gave me the knowledge to have meaningful discussions with my engineers and be able to ask them better questions."

    Tom Parkman, Plant Manager, Simonds International.
  • “Principles of Metallurgy exceeded my expectations. The content was straightforward enough not to be burdensome, yet deep enough to provide a practical review of fundamental principles. I recommend this course to any engineer or technical person who has been out of school and working in industry for several years, but not necessarily having been focused on metallurgy.”

    Andy Jacobs, Staff Engineer, DePuy Orthopaedics, Inc.
  • “The Principles of Metallurgy course is broke up into convenient length modules that can be fit into the busiest schedule. The course is a good review for engineers who had a materials class ten or more years ago.”

    Paul Flury B/E Aerospace
  • “This is an excellent course (Metallurgy of Steel Heat Treating) for learning basic heat treating practices. The course introduces and covers a broad range of processes. I would recommend it for anyone in the steel business.”

    Jim Marks, Magellan Corporation
  • “This course has given me more confidence in my job and given me a better understanding of some of the heat treatments used in the business.”

    Mark Winter, Abbey Forged Products

Have more questions? Email mpfeifer@imetllc.com or call 847.528.3467

Why Industrial Metallurgists?

  • Practical, up-to-date content.
  • Metallurgy expertise and 20+ years of experience.
  • Courses designed for non-metallurgists.
  • Training accessible from anywhere with internet access.
  • Engaging content.
  • Convenience. Learn when it suits your schedule.
  • Avoid being overwhelmed with too much information at one time. Set your own pace.